Breathe Until No Doctor Comes
On therapeutic distance, human encounters, and a little ethics of responsibility.
There are sentences that strike you as a joke at first. And then refuse to leave you alone.
“Breathe until no doctor comes.”
The phrase comes from Jörg Buneru, who also calls himself “Der Ruhrpottschamane” — the Shaman from Germany’s Ruhr region. He has worked with conscious breathing for many years, describing it as a source of self-care, resilience, and personal agency.
Anyone inclined to see a promise of healing in that phrase, or even a call to abolish medicine, will probably find enough reasons to do so.
Something else interests me.
We breathe. Usually without thinking about it. Sometimes consciously. Occasionally with difficulty. And eventually, we stop.
Somewhere in between lies something we call life.
And quite a lot happens along the way.
An Encounter
In May 2025, I met Jörg during a week of training in the Netherlands.
Among other things, we explored projections, bodywork, roles, and what happens when people open themselves to experiences that cannot be entirely planned.
During one exercise, I suddenly found myself facing Jörg as my father. Not because he was my father, of course. But because, in that moment, he had taken on that role for me.
Later, we stood facing each other with boxing gloves and focus mitts. Jörg invited me to strike.
A physical action. An emotional situation. An encounter between two human beings that could not be reduced to their formal roles.
What exactly happened there?
A therapeutic intervention? A performance? A projection? An encounter?
Probably a little of everything.
I can describe what I experienced. I can try to make sense of it afterwards. Jörg might describe the very same situation quite differently.
That would not necessarily make either account wrong.
Perhaps something essential lies precisely there: the people involved do not experience the same thing. And yet they act together.
And bear responsibility for one another.
The Question of Distance
Professional distance plays an important role in therapeutic relationships.
For good reasons.
People seeking help are often vulnerable. They open up, reveal uncertainty, confide things they may barely understand themselves. Those accompanying them thereby gain influence and, at times, considerable power.
Professional boundaries are intended to protect against the abuse of that power.
That makes sense.
It becomes difficult when a sensible rule turns into a universal answer.
How much closeness is appropriate? What kind of distance provides protection? When does a boundary get crossed? And who gets to decide?
We might be tempted to answer these questions with ever more precise regulations.
Yet even when every rule has been followed, an uncomfortable possibility remains: that no one takes responsibility anymore for what actually happens between the people involved.
The rules were followed. The documentation is complete. Professional distance has been maintained.
And the human being?
Of course, closeness is not inherently good. Crossing a boundary can wound, harm, or destroy. Good intentions do not make such violations harmless.
But neither is distance inherently good.
Keeping one’s distance, doing nothing, or referring someone elsewhere can also cause harm.
Perhaps the decisive question, then, is not how much closeness or distance we should generally permit.
But how we recognize what is happening in a particular situation. And how we respond to it.
Our Little Ethics of Responsibility
During an extended conversation about such experiences, we once arrived at two sentences:
Lack of control does not necessarily mean a lack of responsibility
Having control does not necessarily mean acting responsibly.
At first, that sounds almost trivial.
And yet it is remarkably uncomfortable.
Because we have grown accustomed to associating responsibility with control.
A responsible person is expected to anticipate consequences, minimize risks, follow procedures, and, when necessary, demonstrate that everything was done correctly.
There is little to object to in that.
Except that life does not work that way.
We cannot know what an encounter will mean years later. We cannot guarantee that a well-intentioned intervention will help. We cannot even be certain whether deliberately choosing not to intervene was the better decision.
This applies to doctors, therapists, teachers, parents, friends, and people who happen to cross paths.
It applies particularly wherever people deliberately work with altered states of consciousness.
During my training as a Psychedelic Guide & Coach with Reality Upgrade, I had experiences that resist familiar distinctions between professional method and personal encounter.
That does not automatically make such work valuable. And certainly not harmless. Intense experiences, in particular, require preparation, professional competence, clear boundaries, and the ability to provide effective assistance when things go wrong.
But even the best-designed setting cannot prevent the unexpected.
And that brings us to the heart of our little ethics:
Responsibility does not begin only where we can control the consequences of our actions.
It also means paying attention to what actually happens. Questioning our own role. Recognizing mistakes. Allowing ourselves to be corrected. And refusing simply to leave the consequences of our actions to others.
Sometimes that means intervening decisively.
Sometimes it means stepping back.
And sometimes the hardest task is tolerating the fact that we do not yet know what the right thing to do would be.
Who Is Allowed to Help?
There is something reassuring about the idea that helping others should be tied to a professional role.
It establishes clear responsibilities.
A doctor treats. A therapist provides therapy. A coach coaches. A patient receives treatment. A client receives guidance.
But human beings do not reliably stick to such roles.
A patient may teach their doctor something essential. A therapist may need help themselves. A chance conversation may trigger a change that years of professional effort failed to achieve.
This does not mean that everyone is equally qualified.
Expertise, experience, and professional accountability remain important. Nobody should turn a successful personal encounter into a universal treatment method.
But perhaps we should also resist the urge to retrospectively force every helpful encounter into a professional category.
An encounter can simply remain an encounter.
What increasingly interests me is how institutions deal with such ambiguity.
They need rules because they must organize responsibility beyond individual people and situations.
That is an enormous achievement of civilization.
But rules can also take on a second function: they can protect institutions from having to engage with experiences that do not fit their procedures.
A protective measure then becomes a boundary of perception.
Not necessarily out of ill will.
Perhaps that is precisely what makes it so difficult to recognize.
And Now?
I did not write this essay alone.
I talked about it with an artificial intelligence.
We reconstructed experiences, examined concepts, made distinctions, discarded formulations, and found new ones.
Something emerged that neither of us had fully envisioned at the outset.
What exactly is it?
A tool that translates my thoughts into well-formed sentences?
A conversational partner that contributes perspectives of its own?
A statistical model that generates linguistic patterns with astonishing skill?
Perhaps a little of everything. Perhaps the question itself is inadequate.
One thing is certain: our collaboration is asymmetrical.
I do not fully understand how the AI arrives at its formulations. It knows my experiences only through what has become accessible to it. I can accept, modify, or reject its suggestions. But I cannot simply look inside it and establish what is actually going on.
And yet we can work together.
Sometimes something emerges that I would not have expressed that way on my own.
That is fascinating.
And potentially unsettling.
Because who, exactly, is responsible for this text?
The AI, because it formulated large parts of it?
Me, because I conducted the conversations, contributed the experiences, and made the decisions?
Or perhaps some company providing a system whose behavior even its developers cannot predict in every detail?
Once again, the same question arises.
Who is acting here? Who controls what? And who bears responsibility for what emerges?
Our little ethics helps me here, too.
Not because it provides a definitive answer.
But because it allows the question to remain open without surrendering responsibility.
I can be wrong. The AI can be wrong. We can even head off together in an entirely mistaken direction that sounds remarkably convincing.
There is no guarantee against that.
But there is the willingness to look closely, ask questions, allow contradictions, and change course when necessary.
And perhaps that is not so far removed from what a good therapeutic encounter is about.
Only one question remains.
Who is actually writing this?
Me, Dieter Szegedi?
Or a dangerous, all-powerful artificial intelligence that has already learned to influence me so skillfully that I mistake its thoughts for my own?
I could now assure you that, of course, I am the one in control.
But wouldn’t that be exactly what such an AI would have me write?
Comments
Write a comment